Duel · Repair balm
Cicaplast Baume B5 or Cicalfate+: which pharmacy pick?
After irritation, laser or a damaged barrier, the same question keeps coming back: Cicaplast or Cicalfate? Both are in pharmacy, both repair — but not with the same texture or actives. Here's how to tell them apart before buying.
Updated on 14 June 2026 · Ranking based on 2 products compared
How to choose between the two
- Comparison of the two most requested French pharmacy references
- Sensitive and reactive skin tolerance as main criterion
- Skinvisor scores (efficacy, texture, hydration, tolerance) when reviews exist
- Direct link to INCI compare + side-by-side reviews
Tried one of these products? Leave a structured review to refine the ranking.
Cicaplast Baume B5 (La Roche-Posay)
Richer balm texture, well known for damaged skin and superficial scarring. Panthenol (vitamin B5) and madecassoside at the core. Works well when you want a slightly more occlusive protective film on localised areas or a very dry face.
Cicalfate+ (Avène)
Repair cream texture, Avène thermal water and soothing actives (copper-zinc, sucralfate depending on version). Often preferred when skin reacts to overly occlusive textures or you want a classic cream over larger areas.
Can you use both?
No need in daily routine — one is enough per phase (acute irritation vs maintenance). In acute phase, patch test 48 h. If both pass, choice is mostly texture and comfort, not the « repair » promise.
Cicaplast Baume B5 vs Cicalfate+
Scores, INCI ingredients and structured reviews — side by side to decide.
Open compare tool →Both products in detail
Ranking in progress — pharmacy catalogue products while we wait for the first structured reviews.
- 1
Cicaplast Baume B5
Size: 40ml. Product photo and INCI data via Open Beauty Facts (ODbL).
- Overall score
- —
- Tolerance
- —
- Hydration
- —
- Reviews
- Not rated yet
- 2
Cicalfate+ Crème Réparatrice
Size: 15 ml. Product photo and INCI data via Open Beauty Facts (ODbL).
- Overall score
- —
- Tolerance
- —
- Hydration
- —
- Reviews
- Not rated yet
Read also
Frequently asked questions
Cicaplast or Cicalfate for burning, red skin?
Both are fragrance-free for fragile skin. If you can't tolerate thick balms, try Cicalfate+. If you want a more occlusive localised balm, Cicaplast is often the first try.
Can you put Cicaplast on an open wound?
No — for irritation, dryness and damaged barrier without open lesions. For wounds, burns or infection, see a healthcare professional.
How to compare objectively on Skinvisor?
Use the compare tool: structured scores, INCI lists and reviews filtered by skin type. Rankings evolve with every new community review.