← Guides

Repair · Sensitive skin

Cicaplast, Cicalfate, XeraCalm… which repair balm to choose?

After irritation, laser or an eczema flare, everyone ends up asking « Cicaplast or Cicalfate? ». Both work — but not the same way depending on texture tolerance and barrier state. Here's how they place in real reviews.

Updated on 12 June 2026 · Ranking based on 5 balms compared

Our methodology

  • Repair balms and creams (Cicaplast, Cicalfate, XeraCalm, Lipikar…)
  • Tolerance first when skin is inflamed, hydration second
  • Pharmacy brands only
  • Recalculated with every new review

Tried one of these products? Leave a structured review to refine the ranking.

Our selection

Ranking in progress — pharmacy catalogue products while we wait for the first structured reviews.

  1. 1
    Cicalfate+ Crème Réparatrice — Avène

    Avène

    Cicalfate+ Crème Réparatrice

    Size: 15 ml. Product photo and INCI data via Open Beauty Facts (ODbL).

    Overall score
    —
    Tolerance
    —
    Hydration
    —
    Reviews
    Not rated yet
    View product & reviews →View on Amazon →
  2. 2
    EPITHELIALE AH DUO Crème réparatrice "belle peau" — A-Derma

    A-Derma

    EPITHELIALE AH DUO Crème réparatrice "belle peau"

    Product photo and INCI data via Open Beauty Facts (ODbL).

    Overall score
    —
    Tolerance
    —
    Hydration
    —
    Reviews
    Not rated yet
    View product & reviews →View on Amazon →
  3. 3
    Exomega Control Baume — A-Derma

    A-Derma

    Exomega Control Baume

    Size: 500ml. Product photo and INCI data via Open Beauty Facts (ODbL).

    Overall score
    —
    Tolerance
    —
    Hydration
    —
    Reviews
    Not rated yet
    View product & reviews →View on Amazon →
  4. 4
    Lipikar Baume AP+M — La Roche-Posay

    La Roche-Posay

    Lipikar Baume AP+M

    Size: 200 ml. Product photo and INCI data via Open Beauty Facts (ODbL).

    Overall score
    —
    Tolerance
    —
    Hydration
    —
    Reviews
    Not rated yet
    View product & reviews →View on Amazon →
  5. 5
    Nuxuriance Gold Baume Nuit — Nuxe

    Nuxe

    Nuxuriance Gold Baume Nuit

    Size: 50ml. Product photo and INCI data via Open Beauty Facts (ODbL).

    Overall score
    —
    Tolerance
    —
    Hydration
    —
    Reviews
    Not rated yet
    View product & reviews →View on Amazon →

View full category catalogue →

Read also

Frequently asked questions

Red, burning irritated skin: which first?

Fragrance-free formula with panthenol or copper-zinc. Cicaplast Baume B5 and Cicalfate+ come up most often — patch test a small area if very reactive.

Repair balm or daily moisturiser?

Balm for emergency phases or very dry skin. Daily moisturiser is enough the rest of the time. No need for Cicaplast every day if skin is fine.

How do you rank them?

Tolerance first, hydration second. Reviews mostly describe whether the product actually calms or feels suffocating / filmy.